top of page

Your Favourite Tool Isn't a Method

2 days ago
3 min read
A guide to a methodological choice
How to make a choice of method

Organisations rarely lack tools for change. What they lack is the discipline to choose them for the outcome they need, rather than for familiarity or popularity. A favourite tool isn't a method. Used on the wrong job, the wrong tool can do more harm than no tool at all.

In my last post, I argued that change needs a method because common sense isn't common. Here the argument is that a shared framework gives people the same language and the same answer to "what's the method?" But having a method is only half the challenge. The other half is making the right choice about method.


Choosing for the effect

We have a fair collection of machinery on the farm: a mower, a slasher, a rotary hoe, a ripper with tines. Each is a good tool. None is the right tool for everything.

The front paddock by the river is meant to feel like parkland: green, soft and spongy underfoot, with well-cared-for soil. That effect decides the tool. The mower gets the job most of the year. I wouldn't take the ripper to it simply because I like the ripper.

The ripper has its place, though. When we arrived at the farm, that paddock was heavily pugged (holes punched in the soil by cows). It had been left wet and overgrown, with a stand of old fruit trees rotting in waterlogged ground. Compacted soil like that is exactly what tines are for. Two enormous pear trees on the edge survived, and they've thrived since the management of the ground has changed.

The lesson cuts both ways. The right tool for the conditions repaired the ground. The same tool, used out of habit on the paddock as it is now, would tear it up.


The organisational version

I see organisations take a one-size-fits-all approach to this challenge quite a bit. Someone arrives with a favourite tool and says, "Here it is, get stuck in." Nobody asks whether it will make the difference the work needs.

One example has stayed with me. An organisation I worked in wanted to do some work to improve the functioning of its teams. I suggested the Team Diagnostic Survey, developed by Ruth Wageman and Richard Hackman at Harvard. It measures six conditions that its developers report account for around 80% of the variance in team effectiveness. As a licensed practitioner, I could even get us a discount.

The answer was no. What they wanted instead was Patrick Lencioni's The Five Dysfunctions of a Team.

I like Lencioni's book. It's in my library, and it tells a good story. But it's a leadership fable (how the author describes it), and the peer-reviewed evidence that its model improves team performance is thin. The organisation chose the tool it found appealing over the one with an evidence base behind it. In fact, one of the managers involved in the decision to use Lencioni's book revealed that he had already studied this work twice and was looking forward to number 3!

That's not a crime. It's fine to like things. The problem is choosing on liking alone, without asking what outcome the tool is likely to produce.


Activity is not impact

This is where tool choice connects to System Noise. Let's be clear: a poorly matched tool still generates plenty of activity – workshops, reports, conversations, and a sense that something is being done. What it doesn't reliably produce is the change the organisation needed. While the effort is real, the effect is left to chance.

That's why the value I offer isn't access to tools. There are plenty available, including a few free ones on my own site that anyone can try. They're a bit like picking up a line trimmer from Bunnings: useful, accessible and worth a go. The harder question is to do with diagnosis. What challenge are you facing, and will this tool make the difference it needs?


The questions worth asking

So, before your next change initiative reaches for that familiar framework, ask three questions:

  1. What effect do we need?

  2. What does the evidence say?

  3. Does it fit the conditions?

If you can't answer these effectively, you're not choosing a method. You're bringing a ripper to mow the lawn.

If you'd like to start with the diagnosis rather than the tool, my free Change Im

pact Diagnostic is a good place to begin.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page